In the summer of 1996, Maria Farmer barricaded herself behind furniture in a guest house on Leslie Wexner’s sprawling Ohio estate, heart racing after Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell violently assaulted her while she worked on an art project. She had come to escape threats and pursue her painting dreams, but now she was trapped for 12 agonizing hours, security refusing to let her leave. Finally freed when her father drove from Kentucky to rescue her, Maria learned the horrifying truth: her 16-year-old sister Annie had also been abused months earlier at Epstein’s New Mexico ranch—groped, harassed, subjected to an inappropriate topless massage under the guise of relaxation.
Shaken and furious, Maria picked up the phone that August, dialing the FBI and New York police to report the assaults, the stolen nude photos of her underage sisters, and Epstein’s predatory behavior—the first victims to alert authorities.
Yet the warnings vanished into silence, justice delayed nearly a decade while the nightmare continued for countless others.
In the summer of 1996, 26-year-old artist Maria Farmer barricaded herself behind furniture in a guest house on Leslie Wexner’s sprawling estate in New Albany, Ohio. Her heart raced as she pushed chairs and tables against the door, desperate to create a barrier between herself and the nightmare unfolding. She had come to this quiet, heavily guarded property seeking creative freedom—an opportunity to work on a painting commission for a film, away from the chaos of New York City. Jeffrey Epstein, who had hired her as an art scout and promised to advance her career, had arranged the stay in a home he controlled on Wexner’s vast land, complete with armed security and strict oversight from Wexner’s team.
What began as professional promise turned horrific. Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell visited the house multiple times that summer. On one fateful night, they lured Maria into a bedroom under the pretense of conversation. There, she alleges, they violently sexually assaulted her. The attack left her terrified and humiliated. She fled the room, barricading herself in another part of the house. For 12 agonizing hours, she remained trapped—Wexner’s security guards refused to let her leave, dismissing her pleas and blocking any escape. She called family, her mentor artist Eric Fischl, and attempted to contact authorities, but help felt impossibly distant.
Finally, her father drove through the night from Kentucky to rescue her. Only when he arrived did the guards relent, allowing Maria to flee the estate. Shaken and furious, she pieced together the deeper horror: months earlier, in April 1996, her 16-year-old sister Annie had visited Epstein at his Zorro Ranch in New Mexico. There, under the guise of relaxation, Maxwell had given Annie an inappropriate topless massage, while Epstein groped her, harassed her, and crawled into bed with her. Epstein had also taken or stolen nude photographs of Maria’s underage sisters, images he kept and possibly distributed.
Determined to stop the predation, Maria acted swiftly. In late August 1996—around August 26—she contacted the New York City Police Department to report the assaults on herself and the abuse of her sister, including the stolen child pornography. The NYPD directed her to the FBI. She followed up, calling federal agents to detail Epstein’s predatory behavior, the exploitation of minors, and the existence of explicit images. It was the first formal complaint against Epstein and Maxwell to reach law enforcement.
Yet those warnings vanished into institutional silence. The FBI took no immediate action; no investigation followed for nearly a decade. Epstein’s operation continued unchecked, ensnaring countless young women and girls in a web of trafficking and abuse that spanned years and continents. Maria and Annie’s courage in speaking out—despite fear, isolation, and disbelief—marked an early, ignored cry for justice.
The delay haunted Maria. She later reflected that prompt investigation could have halted Epstein’s crimes far sooner, sparing hundreds of victims decades of trauma. In 2006, the FBI finally interviewed her amid the Palm Beach probe, but by then, the damage was immense. Epstein’s 2008 plea deal shielded him further, and it wasn’t until his 2019 arrest, Maxwell’s 2021 conviction, and subsequent document releases—including confirmation of Maria’s 1996 FBI complaint—that her role as the first whistleblower gained wider recognition.
Maria Farmer’s barricaded night and defiant phone calls embody a survivor’s unyielding fight against powerful silence. Though justice arrived late, her actions planted seeds that eventually helped dismantle a monstrous enterprise.
Leave a Reply